This summer, Lockheed Martin and Joint Program Office are mobilizing their PR departments once again after a not-so-complimentary report was leaked detailing the F-35's lack of dogfighting prowess. Some have dismissed the report as "garbage" (yet still slam the JSF for being a "bloated failure"). Whatever the merit of the report, it is still a harsh blow to a program that once boasted of the JSF's superiority compared to fourth-generation fighters.
This latest bit of PR shenanigans may soon be forgotten if this next shoe drops, however...
In a document addressed to the United States of America's Senate Armed Services Committee, (SASC), Marine General Joseph Dunford addressed questions about the F-35's troubles thusly:
[QUESTION:] “Do you believe the nation can afford to procure these aircraft at a cost of $12B to $15B per year for nearly the next 20 years for an aircraft design that will be 30 years old at the completion of the program procurement phase?”
[ANSWER:] “Given the evolving defense strategy and the latestDefense Planning Guidance, we are presently taking the newest strategic foundation and analyzing whether 2,443 aircraft is the correct number."
This could be big.
This could mean that the Pentagon is looking at purchasing more F-35s, but given the context, it seems unlikely. While the U.S. Military seems to have undying patience for the JSF program, the politicians in charge of the pursestrings do not.
Internationally, the Joint Strike Fighter has not quite met the sales expectations envisioned at the start of the program. While some orders have trickled in, most partner nations have drastically cut their intended numbers. Others have decided to "wait and see" while upgrading and extending the life of older fighter inventories. Some, like Canada and Denmark, have "reset" in order to examine other options.
Bottom line: The F-35 will not sell as well internationally as originally hoped. If the USA decides to cut its numbers, there could be trouble for the program. The JSF depends on economies of scale to help bring down unit price. As sales decrease, the unit price increases. As price increases, sales decrease. (etc, etc...) This could lead to the infamous "death spiral".
I have stated before that the "death spiral" is an unlikely scenario. There is too much invested already to deem the aircraft a complete failure and start fresh. Instead, numbers will be drastically cut and the F-35 will become more of a niche aircraft like the B-1B or F-22 instead of next F-16.
Like a proverbial zombie, the JSF program will continue to shuffle along... But rotten chunks of it are starting to fall off.
In news that will surely have repercussions to the JSF program, the United States Navy has chosen to cut back their F-35C orders until 2020 by as much as a third.
Instead, the USN will pursue more stand-off weapons (ie: ALCMs).
"The Navy’s budget priorities reflect the views of Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Jonathan Greenert. In June 2012, shortly after he was appointed as CNO, Greenert published an article in the Naval Institute’s Proceedings magazine that downplayed the importance of advanced platforms, including stealth aircraft, in favor of “payloads” including standoff weapons."
In order for the F-35 to meet its production goals over the next few years, those USN sales will have to be made up some other way. Otherwise, its price will remain high, resulting in the "death spiral" or, at least, a "zombie shuffle".
Israel, one of the JSF's staunchest supporters since its inception, has drastically reduced its F-35 order. Instead of an initial order for 31 stealth fighters, the Israeli government has only approved funding for 14. This is thanks to the fact that the F-35 simply is not ready yet. Israeli Intelligence Minister Yuval Steinitz had this to say:
“Since the plane is not yet operational in the US, I suggested that we make do with the purchase of less than half the amount, and wait with decisions on purchasing additional jets, as several other countries – like Australia, Italy, Canada and Holland – have done.”
It seems as though everybody wants a piece of the JSF's industrial benefits, but at the same time is having cold feet when it comes to actually purchasing the aircraft in sufficient amounts.
Published: By:
Unknown
- 8:32 AM
Now another bombshell has dropped regarding the F-35's Pratt & Whitney F135 turbofan engine.
Pratt & Whitney has had to halt deliveries of the F135 over concerns over the titanium used. This is due to issues with subcontractors that have been under pressure to lower costs. Pratt & Whitney has been accused of poor management over this:
The Defense Contract Management Agency wrote in a June internal assessment that Pratt & Whitney’s “continued poor management of suppliers is a primary driver for the increased potential problem notifications.”
The incidents “have resulted in delinquent deliveries of engines,” the agency said. “This trend will continue until the contractor improves its management of subcontractors and suppliers.”
Now comes word that Pratt & Whitney have not delivered a F135 engine since May. Worse still, this fact has been kept under wraps since then. Not only is this a public relations faux pas, but is also raises some serious questions, as listed on Defense-Aerospace:
All of the above paints a pretty dismal picture of the credibility of the F-35 program and of the ease with which it manipulates the media. But the media is not alone is having been misled:
-- Witnesses during June-July hearings by four congressional panels on the FY2015 budget also neglected to mention the engine delivery freeze. The cover-up is a slap in the face of these panels, whose reaction this week will be indicative of how seriously they take their oversight role.
-- Was the British government, the biggest foreign partner in the F-35 program, informed of this latest setback, and did it join the cover-up? Was this the reason it didn’t sign the 14-aircraft order, as expected?
-- Was the Italian government, the second-largest foreign partner, informed, and were the six other foreign partners who have contributed to funding development? Were they kept deliberately in the dark, or did they join the cover-up?
In other words, is this an international conspiracy to protect the F-35 from parliamentary and public scrutiny, or is it simply a domestic cover-up in the US?
The cover-up also raises shareholder information issues for Lockheed Martin and United Technologies, Pratt’s corporate parent. Lockheed, for example, makes no mention of the engine freeze in its July 22 statement on second quarter results, although the F-35 program is so crucial to its future that it is specifically mentioned in its “Forward Looking Statement” regulatory warning.
It would appear as though the media, elected government officials, international partners, and shareholders for both Lockheed Martin and Pratt & Whitney have been kept in the dark about this. If so, expect the worse for the F-35. American mid-terms are coming up and tensions in the Ukraine and with ISIS has put military spending front and center.
As hard as summer was on the F-35 Lightning II program, this autumn might get even harder.
Published: By:
Unknown
- 6:36 PM
Saab and Boeing dropped a bombshell late last year when they announced that they would be joining forces to submit a bid for the upcoming T-X program. The T-X program intends to replace the venerable T-38 Talon in use by the USAF as a high performance jet trainer.
What will this collaboration look like? Early reports on a "decontented" Saab Gripen have been dispelled. This will be an "all new" aircraft. Given the context of the T-X program, it is very likely that much of the project will be off-the-shelf in order to keep risk and costs down.
Designing an all new aircraft does give put the Saab/Boeing T-X bid in a riskier position than the other T-X contenders. All the other bidders are proposing existing aircraft in order to keep risks to a minimum. Lockheed Martin is partnering up with Korean KAI in offering the T-50 Golden Eagle, Northrop Grumman is partnering with BAE in offering the Hawk T2/128, and Alenia Aermacchi is offering the M-346 Master.
Looking at the other contenders, the Lockheed Martin/KAI T-50 is the obvious front-runner. It is a fairly new design and a fine performer by the looks of it. It certainly does not hurt to have Lockheed Martin's massive marketing behind it either. The BAE Hawk is a 40-year-old design, not to mention subsonic. It is a fine trainer, but it is hard to imagine it being relevant for another 30-50 years. The M-346 Master is an underdog. Not only does it lack Lockheed or Boeing's marketing push, but the design is based on the Russian Yak-130. Needless to say, this could render the design unpalatable in today's political climate.
Saab and Boeing would likely be able to get away with going a similar route as the competition. The Gripen is little more "high end" than the others, but a JAS 39D with a cruder radar, no weapon systems, and perhaps a more generic GE F404 engine replacing the Volvo RM12 would bring costs down. Boeing's mighty manufacturing prowess combined with economies of scale would do the rest.
Too easy?
So why are Boeing and Saab taking the risk of an all new design?
Perhaps the risk is not as bad as it seems. There is already some trepidation about Lockheed Martin being the only fighter manufacturer in the USA. Not only does it raise concerns financially, but strategically as well. Yet when Boeing ceases production of the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet and F-15 Eagle within a few years, this will be the case. The idea of buying hundreds of foreign designed aircraft as fighter-trainers only emphasizes this. Producing an "all new" aircraft of American heritage actually gives Boeing a considerable political advantage.
Another factor is the possible disadvantage held by the front-runner, the KAI T-50. Lockheed Martin backing may actually backfire as issues continue with the F-35. There are rumors that problems and delays with the Northrop B-2 did little favors for the YF-23 Black Widow when it lost to the Lockheed Martin YF-22.
Issues with the F-35 may have another benefit for Saab and Boeings upcoming T-X contender. As costs go up and problems arise, some have questioned the possibility of an alternative. At the very least, there may need to be a lower cost option to supplement a smaller-than-expected JSF fleet. A cheaper, simpler aircraft would also likely make sense for the Air National Guard or for tasks like aggressor training.
First and foremost, Boeing and Saab will have to present an affordable and adaptable trainer capable of replacing the T-38 Talon. This entails several things:
Affordability is a priority. Not just in procurement, but in operation.
Risk must be kept to an absolute minimum.
This aircraft will prepare pilots for the F-22, F-35, NGB, and "6th generation" aircraft not even conceived yet.
There is a high likelihood of the T-X being used as a "companion trainer" to allow pilots to keep their flight hours up without flying expensive aircraft like the F-22.
Adoption of a "aggressor" trainer seems likely.
The T-X will likely see many upgrades and modifications over the years to remain relevant.
While the T-X is a USAF project, the USN is involved, and further sales are likely.
While 350 aircraft would be enough to replace the T-38, there is the potential demand here for 1000 or even more aircraft. Certainly well worth the risk.
With all that in mind, let us peer into the crystal ball...
General Layout:
Boeing's unsuccessful (and ugly) X-32
Since risk needs to be minimized, it is likely that both Boeing and Saab will go for what they know.
Saab certainly prefers the single engined delta wing. Its last two fighter designs, the JAS-39 Gripen and the J-37 Viggen were both delta/canard layouts. Before that, the J-35 Draken was a cranked or "double delta" design.
Boeing likely has mixed feeling towards the delta layout. Its unsuccessful JSF contender, the X-32 started out as a delta-wing design. Built as a single piece, this large delta wing would have provided for large internal fuel capacity and reduced drag. It proved difficult to manufacturer, however, and changes in the performance required by the USN resulted in a change to a more conventional (yet still ugly) design. Before finalizing the more conventional layout, a pelikan tail was considered to reduce drag and improve stealthiness. Boeing opted against this, however.
Nope. Still ugly.
At the very top of this post, you will notice a picture of a Boeing T-X concept that was released before it announced its partnership with Saab. While the T-38 and F-18 influences are obvious, the pelikan tail seems rather conspicuous. The tail not only mimics that of the YF-23 Black Widow, but McDonnell Douglas/BAE/Northrop Grumman's JSF proposal. While the T-X has no need to be a true stealth aircraft, it likely would not hurt for it to be a "stealthier" aircraft. Not only would a pelikan tail allow for this, but the decreased drag would result in lower fuel consumption as well.
A pelikan tail does have disadvantages. Since it uses two larger control surfaces instead of four smaller ones, it requires beefier hydraulics to move them. In the X-32's case, that would have added up to 900 pounds to an aircraft already pushing its weight limits thanks to a STOVL requirement. This extra weight would be less consequential on a CTOL-only trainer, however.
Saab's FS2020 concept model
Perhaps the "all-new" design already exists. Saab has shown its own Flygsystem (Flight System) 2020 that envisions an indigenous stealth aircraft for the Swedish Air Force. This FS2020 concept looks very much like a "stealth" Gripen with a pelican tail.
Looking at the FS2020, the McDonnell Douglas JSF, and Boeing's T-X concept art reveals a clear direction. The Boeing/Saab T-X will likely be a single-engined delta-winged aircraft with a pelikan tail. Perhaps Saab's influence will lead to it incorporating canards, possibly to mitigate the extra size and weight required for the pelikan tail.
The FS2020 concept, or something close to it, could very well be the chosen design. It has already undergone some wind-tunnel and sub-scale testing.
Engine:
General Electric F414 turbofan.
The Saab/Boeing T-X will almost undoubtedly be a single-engine design. A single engine reduces maintenance and fuel costs. There would seem to be little benefit in going with a twin-engine design.
The choice of engine can be easily narrowed down. Both Saab and Boeing currently use derivatives of General Electric's F404 and F414 turbofans. The legacy Hornets use the F404 while the Gripen thus far uses the Volvo RM12 which is heavily based on the same. Both manufacturers use the F414 on their newer Super Hornet and Gripen NG designs.
Given that the F414 is a newer design that may even be offered on the KAI T-50, which currently uses F404s, it seems likely that the GE F414 will be the default engine choice on the Saab/Boeing T-X.
Cockpit:
Advanced Super Hornet cockpit mock-up.
It is quickly becoming apparent that "all-glass" cockpits are here to stay. First seen in the F-35, large touch screens are now being promoted for updated versions of the Gripen, Super Hornet, and Silent Eagle. This is not just a trend, it is the future. These reconfigurable touch screens not only prioritize important information, but they can quickly change depending on the mission type. Upgrades are also made easier, as a simply software patch can improve the man/machine interface.
For a next generation trainer, the "all glass" cockpit offers additional advantages. Displays could have several "skins" that more closely resemble that of trainee's intended aircraft. Not only that, but flight software could also be modified to make the T-X perform like other aircraft. This could include (but not limited to) restricting afterburner use, g-limits, or controlling stick inputs. In essence, this would be giving the T-X a set of virtual "training wheels".
Sensors:
Saab Gripen E's AESA radar and IRST.
The current USAF trainer, the T-38 Talon, goes without IRST or even a radar. Its avionics package merely includes rudimentary flight sensors, navigation, and communication equipment. It would seem likely that the T-X will have little need for either as well. A data-link of some sort would likely be the most important upgrade, as this would help prepare pilots for the advanced data links found in the F-22 and F-35.
The "base model" T-X has little need for a radar or IRST, but it is likely that space will be available for such. This gives Boeing and Saab more leeway in adopting the T-X into a combat ready fighter. At the very least, it makes the T-X a more tempting candidate for use as an "Aggressor" trainer. USAF aggressor trainers are already being outfitted with IRST pods to better mimic potential adversaries.
More advanced sensors, like the F-35's DAS and EOTS systems, seem unlikely. Not only do they add additional cost and complexity, but their value on a training system would be dubious. Like the radar and IRST, this may be another item that will not be standard issue, but space is available for future upgrades.
Weapons:
F-15SE's conformal weapon bay (CWB)
As a trainer, even as an aggressor, the T-X will have little need for weapon storage. At most, a handful of pylons would be needed for mounting items like targeting pods and the like. Internal weapon storage would be completely unnecessary and would only serve to increase development risk with no real payoff.
But... What if I told you there was a way for Boeing and Saab to add internal weapon storage? Not only that, but this method would be nearly risk free, as it has already been tested.
Boeing has been hard at work lately finding ways of making its legacy fighters stealthier. It has self-funded development work on both the F-15E and the Super Hornet, finding ways to mount weapons and extra fuel without the RCS penalty. Boeing has modified the F-15E Strike Eagle's CFTs (formerly known as FAST packs) into conformal weapon bays (CWBs) on the F-15SE Silent Eagle.
Advanced Super Hornet's Enclosed Weapon Pod
Similar work has been done on the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet. Not only does the "Advanced Super Hornet" mount two shoulder mounted CFTs, but it incorporates an "enclosed weapons pod" or EWP. Like the F-15SE's CWBs, the EWP allows for stealthier weapon carriage without the need for a permanent cavity in the aircraft's structure. This not only simplifies the design, but it saves weight, as the aircraft's structure does not have to be reinforced around the weapons bay. As any mechanical engineer will tell you "holes can be heavy".
Possibly the biggest advantage to a CWB or EWP is expandability. A variety of different sized CWBs or EWPs can be made available, depending on the mission. Larger pods could be used to house "bunker busters" or a large amount of smaller bombs, while a smaller pods could be used for air-to-air missiles.
The real opportunity here for the Boeing/Saab T-X is for a design that is "custom built" to mount some sort of CWB or EWP. Instead of being mounted these on a pylon or as an afterthought on the side of the aircraft, the Boeing/Saab T-X could have provisions for special "conformal weapons pods". The most likely mounting points would be on either side of the fuselage, like the F-15SE, and possibly one flush with the bottom centerline of the fuselage, the the Super Hornet above (but without the pylon).
These conformal weapon pods could turn the unarmed T-X trainer into a full-fledged fighter. Not only could they carry missiles and bombs, but they could carry other important items like a targeting pod or a cannon. As time goes on and technology changes, new conformal weapon pods could be developed to allow new weapons without the need to modify the core aircraft.
This modular approach would have benefits for non-warfighting T-Xs as well. Those conformal pods could be used to house camera equipment. One of the T-38's most familiar roles was that of a chase plane. The T-38 was not strictly a USAF aircraft, NASA was a user as well. No doubt those conformal pods would be of use for them.
Boeing and Saab decided to develop an all-new aircraft for a reason. It is difficult to imagine that they will simply aim for a dedicated trainer without any thought to a war fighting version. All of the other T-X contenders have armedversionsavailable, why should Saab and Boeing be left out?
Saab and Boeing's biggest ace in the hole is the F-35's increasing costs and delays. While the JSF is certainly "too big to fail", it certainly is not "too big" to decrease the scope of the program. Cuts to the JSF would free up a great deal of cash for other projects.
The Saab/Boeing T-X could be a sort of "back door" into providing a supplement, and perhaps an alternative to the F-35. By producing a modular, upgradable design that does not have to constrain itself to the JSF's "do everything" mandate, Saab and Boeing might just deliver an aircraft that makes far more financial sense to those having second thoughts about the F-35.
Here, take this. It is a single grain of salt.
Please keep in mind that this is entirely conjecture on my part. Saab and Boeing may have something else up their sleeve entirely, and I have no inside information from which to base any of this on. Saab and Boeing have not revealed any details yet. Their final design may incorporate some, none, or all these musings.
Who knows, there may even be more surprises when the final design is introduced.
A week ago, F-35 flights were suspended after an engine fire. Today, the word is that the JSF fleet is now officially grounded. This is no real surprise. According to one witness “The engine ripped through the top of the plane”. The timing of this comes at a particularly precarious time in the JSF program. European support for the F-35 is less than stellar at the moment. It was hoped that the F-35's presence during the Royal International Air Tattoo (RIAT) and the Farnborough Air Show this month would give JSF boosters something to be proud of. As it is, today's hoped for flyby during the HMS Queen Elizabeth's naming ceremony is off. Instead, the part of the F-35 was played by a 50-year old de Havilland Sea Vixen. Participation at RIAT (July 11th) is as good as cancelled, as the F-35's 36 hour turnaround time would require the grounding be lifted almost immediately. Currently the best that could be hoped for is an appearance at the tail end of the Farnborough Air Show, which begins July 14th and runs until the 20th. This is clearly embarrassing for all those involved. To get a clear picture of how embarrassing, the Pentagon's news release for this came at 9:03PM July 3rd, right before the July 4th long weekend. Known as an "info dump", this practice attempts to bury bad news by releasing it at a time when people's attention are set on other things. It is still unclear what caused the engine fire, or if it is related to the short-lived grounding in in June due to a faulty oil valve. All said this is very bad news for the Joint Strike Fighter program. Almost 10 years behind schedule, billions over budget, and nowhere near the amount of expected orders; the JSF office desperately needs some good PR. Instead, defense ministers are forced to stand beside fiberglass mock-ups instead of the real deal. Any excuse stating that the JSF is still early in its development is delusional. There are currently more F-35s in existence then there are CF-18s in the RCAF. The F-35's first flight was in 2006. Back then, the Apple iPhone was yet to be released. The Hummer H3 was declared "Truck of the Year". George W. Bush was still president of the USA and Stephen Harper became Prime Minister of Canada.
"I was crossing the Atlantic before it was cool."
Eight years, billions of dollars and almost 100 F-35s later, the Lightning II has still not demonstrated the ability to cross the Atlantic ocean. This is feat first accomplished by Charles Lindbergh in the Spirit of Saint Louis back in 1927.
Current plans are for the F-35B to achieve IOC (initial operating capability) with the USMC in late 2015. That leaves slightly over a year to turn a plane that cannot cross the Atlantic because it spontaneously catches on fire into a world-class weapon system capable of engaging hostile threats. Since the F-35's appearance in Britain this month is now very much in doubt, I'll use a popular British term to describe the JSF's current status: OMNISHAMBLES.
There aren't many options for STOVL fighters these days. No options at all, in fact. The only STOVL fighter aircraft currently in production is the Lockheed Martin F-35B Lighting II. Its predecessor, the AV-8 Harrier, was no different. The only other STOVL fighter to make production was the Soviet Yak-38 "Forger".
The F-35B is seen as the de facto choice for organizations operating Harriers. It is the only fighter with STOVL abilities, enabling it to operate from smaller aircraft carriers designed primarily for helicopter operations. This includes the Royal Navy, USMC, Indian Navy, Royal Thai Navy, Italian Navy, and Spanish Navy.
With a monopoly on making STOVL fighters, you'd think Lockheed-Martin's F-35B sales would be shoe-in. Unlike the "A" and "C" models, there are no alternatives to the F-35B, stealthy or no. Yet, F-35B sales are looking incredibly shaky lately.
Spanish AV-8B Harrier II.
Most recently, Spain has decided to forego the F-35B for now. Instead, it will continue to support its AV-8B Harrier II fleet until at least 2025. This isn't especially damning for the JSF program as a whole, as Spain had yet to sign on as a buyer or partner. The numbers are small enough to be inconsequential as well. Currently, the Spanish Navy operates only a single carrier, the Juan Carlo I, with a total fleet of 13 AV-8Bs.
Why is the F-35B looking like a hard sell? You'd think that a supersonic stealth fighter that can take off and land like a helicopter would be in high demand.