Showing posts with label C-17. Show all posts
Showing posts with label C-17. Show all posts

[Rant...] WHY WE WRITE

Don't worry.  This is a one-parter.


It comes around on a seemingly regular basis.

Either here, in the Facebook group, or some other media; someone will spout off that golden nugget that attempts to put a nail through everything I and others like me have tried to do over the last few years.  That nugget reads like the following:
Those close to the F-35 program sing its praises.  Its critics are those who have never flown on it or worked on it.  
It raises an interesting point.

Why trust a random blogger over test pilot who flies the aircraft?  Why trust a scathing aviation reporter when official press releases are saying everything is tickety-boo?  What does it matter to us, anyway?  It isn't as if we will ever fly this airplane.


While it is true that us aviation enthusiasts, bloggers, critics, and other layman are not as "connected" with the program as the pilots, executives, and politicians anchoring their careers to the JSF, there is a very large difference between them and us.  A difference that often goes unnoticed in all the rhetoric.

We are the ones paying for this damn thing.

It is not the military, the government, or the primary contractor (Lockheed Martin in this case) that is the largest stakeholder.  It is the general public, Mr. and Mrs John Q. Taxpayer are the ones picking up the tab.  They are also the ones who will depend on this machinery to defend their freedom.

What Mr. and Mrs. John Q. Taxpayer are seeing isn't pretty.

They see a massive military project that is hundreds of billions of dollars over budget and years late.  They see an aircraft that is so far underwhelming in performing its intended mission.  They even see an aircraft that could be dangerous to the very people flying it.

The JSF is far from the first military project to blow its timeline and budget.  In fact, missed deadlines and red ink seem to have become acceptable over the years.  So much so that it is actually noteworthy when a project does deliver on-time and under budget.

V-22 Osprey:  Eighteen years in development with a projected cost of $36 billion.

So what makes the F-35 any different?

Simply put, it is a matter of scale.  The JSF is the largest, costliest military procurement project to date.  At almost $1.5 trillion (US), the F-35 makes the $45 billion B-2 bomber project cost seem like a footnote.   It puts the $209 billion space shuttle program to shame.

The massive scale of the F-35 program raises the stakes.  Even minor problems can end up costing the taxpayer millions of dollars.  Bigger problems can cost in the tens, or hundreds of billions.  Worse still, since the JSF is intended to replace the vast majority of the western world's fighter fleet, program delays increase the wear-and-tear on the older fighters it is meant to replace, increasing their operating costs.

Still, would it not be easier for us to simply let those in charge do their job?

Boeing C-17 Globemaster III.  Great aircraft...  But why so many?
Well, maybe if we had any faith in those people, but a history of greed and incompetence have made the public wary.

Military procurement is big business.  The world's largest economy (USA) spends the 20% percent of tax revenue on defense.  At about $718 billion in 2011, the USA's defense budget was more than half of Canada's entire gross domestic product (GDP).

Big business and big government spending leads to a "revolving door" where former government and military officials find high-paying work at the very corporations they were once tasked to oversee.  We are assured that everything is on the up-and-up...  But c'mon.

The military-industrial complex has provided us with some real doozies.  A fighter jet isn't just a fighter jet anymore; it's a also a jobs program.  This means that even the most asinine projects are funded well beyond their usefulness.  The C-17 Globemaster III, for instance, has seen its production artificially extended thanks thanks to the whims of US congress rather than the USAF's demand for more cargo aircraft.  As of April of this year, five C-17s remain unsold. 

The Bradley Fighting Vehicle:  Too cramped to be a transport, to slow to be a scout, too fragile to be a tank.

Then there are the worst-case scenarios when bureaucracy conspires to turn a rather straight-forward project into a comedy of errors.

The Bradley Fighting Vehicle was meant to provide the US Army with an armored personnel carrier (APC) with enough firepower to defend itself as well as enough speed to keep up with the M1A1 Abrams main battle tank (MBT).  Attempts to increase the Bradley's versatility led to a machine that failed to deliver on its primary purpose of delivering troops.  Instead of carrying 11 troops like its predecessor, the M113, the Bradley only carried 6.

The Bradley Fighting Vehicle has gone on to see a distinguished career, thanks partially to its bewildering number of variants.  Despite the Bradley's success, it never did work well as a troop carrier.  In fact, the M113, the APC it was meant to replace, still serves as the US Army's predominant troop transport.

The Bradley Fighting Vehicle's saga does not end there, however.  Live fire testing was manipulated to provide a more favorable result, replacing its explosive ammunition stores with cans of water.

The story of the Bradley's development was featured in the book The Pentagon Wars: Reformers Challenge the Old Guard.  This was later developed into a movie comedy (what better way to represent military procurement and development) of the same name (The Pentagon Wars).

Here is a clip, explaining the evolution of the Bradley Fighting Vehicle.


The entirety of The Pentagon Wars can be seen here, free on YouTube.  It is well worth the watch.



Many times, those closest to a program are the least likely to criticize it.  Their career may be on the line, or they might just be to closely involved to see the "big picture".

Throughout the years, the military procurement process has been littered with examples of spending run-amok.  When the tax-paying public is being told that "everything is okay", we have reason to be suspicious.  We demand more than slick PR campaigns and condescending platitudes.

We demand tangible results.  

We demand value for our tax dollar.

We demand the truth.

Is that too much to ask?
Published: By: Unknown - 3:09 PM

Convoy!

Take close look at the following:




What you are looking at is 4 F-35Bs, 2 KC-10 Extenders, 1 C-17 Globemaster III, and 1 KC-130 Hercules.  All together, you are looking at approximately $1 billion worth of hardware.  (Give or take, but I'm being generous here.)

These aircraft you see above will gather soon for a purpose.  That purpose:  So that the JSF can make its international debut in the United Kingdom.  The F-35B is scheduled to perform a flight demonstration at the Royal International Air Tattoo in Fairford, followed by another aerial demonstration in Farnborough.  There is also hope that the F-35B will perform a flyby during the HMS Queen Elizabeth's naming ceremony in Scotland.

Four fighters, two tankers, one heavy transport, one medium transport and around 80 personnel.  That is what is needed in order for the F-35 to perform two air shows and a fly by.  There may be a static display at the Air Tattoo, but the aircraft won't even be landing in Farnborough.  There will be no vertical take off or landing, nor will there be any aerobatics.
“This won’t be a Typhoon display, we are showing the unique aspects of the airplane, but it is not going to be doing 50 Alphas [angle of attack maneuvers] and [pulling] 9gs, because we don’t have that flight clearance,” Nichols says.
“We are not going to do a vertical landing, because the surfaces that we need to have on the deck to conduct such a landing do not exist at Fairford or at Farnborough. Hovering is possible, however, so the role demo will include some maneuvers that show off the potential of the aircraft, along with some high-speed passes.”
It should be noted that while the AV-8 Harrier was capable of landing just about anywhere a helicopter could, the F-35B's exhaust is so hot that vertical landings require as special landing pad.

Despite this measured approach to the F-35's international debut, tensions are high with the JSF program office right now.  Flights were recently grounded due to an oil leak and flights have been suspended after an engine fire last week.
Orlando Carvalho, executive vice president of Lockheed Martin Aeronautics, which manufactures the F-35, says reliable operations will be the most challenging part of the deployment to the U.K. “I know we can do it,” he says, noting that two F-35Bs operated ship-based trials consistently during in 2011 and 2013. But, he acknowledges, keeping the planes flying continuously for both events will be demanding. 
Reliability is “behind where it needs to be” today, Lorraine Martin, F-35 executive vice president, confirms. But as retrofits are infused into new jets on the line—and eventually added to the earlier ones produced—constancy is increasing. The Navy’s small fleet has been far more reliable, she says, because they are among the most recent to roll off the line and include retrofits to faults identified early in the flight-test program.
The pressure behind this transatlantic trip cannot be understated.  There is growing doubt in Europe  over the F-35 program, with Italy possibly cutting its orders further, Spain deciding to keep its AV-8Bs, and growing criticism in Britain.  Being seen at Farnborough, one of the largest aerospace trade shows in the world, was likely considered a "do or die" scenario.  Not only is it important for Lockheed-Martin and the Pentagon, but it is also important for Britain's Defense Secretary Philip Hammond, who would rather not have a photo-op taken with a cardboard cutout.
Hammond is keen to have the aircraft flying at the ceremony to show he is not buying a paper aircraft, and wants to avoid a repetition of events at which other defense ministers posed in front of – or inside – full-scale models when announcing their orders. 
Sound familiar?

Yup...  Never gets old.
Four fighters, two tankers, one heavy transport, one medium transport, and 80 personnel.  Those are the resources required for the F-35 to perform at two air shows and maybe a flyby.  These fighters are not going to some remote part of the world, either.  For their stay in the United Kingdom, the F-35Bs will be stationed out of RAF Fairford, an air force base capable of housing the B-2 bomber.  Not exactly a Forward Operating Location.

Just to put a finer point to this, pay attention to the aircraft below:


For those of you that lost count while scrolling down, that is 10 Saab JAS-39 Gripens and followed by a single C-130 Hercules.  All the equipment and spares needed to support those 10 Gripens for a 4-week expeditionary deployment can be stored in that single Herc...  With room to spare.

Four F-35s, 2 KC-10s, 1 C-17, 1 C-130...  For a couple of air shows out of a major air base.

Ten Gripens and a C-130...  For a 4-week deployment.

Just let that sink in.
Published: By: Unknown - 7:21 PM